redsnake05: Art by Audrey Kawasaki (Up to no good)
[personal profile] redsnake05
I can't believe it's Monday already. All my procrastinatory instincts are on high alert, looking for something that I can be slack about.

Enter Mission Monday - I will be on to it! (or, at the very least, highly caffeinated)
velvetpage: (Default)
[personal profile] velvetpage
I hate giving marks.

I hate the process of figuring out how a dozen different assignments, all relating to different expectations and all taught, supported, and assessed in different ways, go together to create one overarching letter that is supposed to sum up a kid's work for a term.

You know what? It doesn't. There's no way that it can. The same kid can be at three different levels in three different key expectations, and giving them the middle level doesn't recognize either their weaknesses or their strengths well enough to satisfy my professionalism, much less well enough to really represent the kid.

Furthermore, the parents don't look at that A and say, "Wow, you did really well on that brochure assignment! You put a lot of effort into it and used your information well, and your research came from lots of different sources! I'm impressed with your work!" No, the vast majority of parents look at the A and say, "You're really smart in English!"

Then they look at the C+ in number sense and numeration, and instead of saying, "It seems you were really struggling with multiplication. What can we work on together that will help you with that?" they say, "It's okay. Some people just aren't good at math." Which is a better message than the other most likely one: "You're stupid and lazy and that's why you got a low mark." But it's still not the truth. Neither of them are the truth. And since a parent's opinion is necessarily and properly more important to a kid than a teacher's, my repetition of the first message gets drowned out by their repetitions of the other messages.

For the parents out there, please, please, know this: no matter what your personal relationship with grades was in school, you need to put it aside. If there's one message I want to give you, as a teacher trying to improve your child's learning and give them hope for their future, it's this: marks are not a reflection of the child's abilities. They're a reflection of the child's achievement on a certain number of assessment tasks which may or may not accurately reflect the child's understanding of the material and almost certainly do not reflect the child's full potential. If you treat marks as indicators of work already done, and tie them directly to the learning that went into that work, then you'll probably avoid this trap. If you interpret marks as a reflection of your child's aptitudes, you are doing your child a significant disservice. Marks are only as good as the expectations they relate to and the tasks used to assess the child's achievement of that expectation. They do not reflect the child well at all. They're at best a necessary evil, at worst a horrible setback to kids who might otherwise be making great gains.

This rant brought to you by my second-term report cards and the letter C+.
redsnake05: Art by Audrey Kawasaki (Up to no good)
[personal profile] redsnake05
How many of you hear this all the time? It's like a mantra in some circles, but only in the sense that people think that if they repeat it often enough they will magically become a literacy teacher without actually having to do anything.

Read more... )
redsnake05: Art by Audrey Kawasaki (Up to no good)
[personal profile] redsnake05
I recently did DNA with one of my classes, and thought that we should touch on the idea of memes as a way of passing on cultural knowledge. It turned out that no one in the class had ever heard of internet memes, not even lolcats. So I introduced lolcats and demotivators as a five-minute funtime reward at the end of the lesson, having the projector on and flicking through a range of lolcats and demotivators. The students thought it was interesting, and it was nice to give them a reward that was easy. I'm a big fan of five-minute reward times at the end of class.

Unsurprisingly, demotivational posters were their favourites )


teaching: Four colour trees (Default)

April 2017

1617181920 2122


RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 21st, 2017 01:36 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios